Associated Jehovah's Witnesses for Reform on Blood              
Newsletter                                April 2005                                    Volume 2 Issue 1

There has been some delay in publishing the newsletter for which we apologize. Consider- able time has been spent in careful review of the June 15, 2004 Watchtower since this likely establishes official Watchtower policy on blood for several years. As this time, we can inform you that we have published a comprehensive response to the Watchtower study articles.


Medicine & Science
by Lee Elder

One of the more interesting developments over the past year is the reaction of Jehovah's Witnesses and non Jehovah's Witnesses to the testing and use of Polyheme. As you may have read, the FDA has approved a study which will allow the oxygen carrying blood product (produced from human red blood cells) to be administered at the scene of an accident without the permission of the injured person.

This study is being conducted in selected cities to assess the efficacy of hemoglobin based blood products and there has been room for public comment in the cities selected for study. The news reports have shown that a number of Jehovah's Witnesses have strongly objected and taken steps to opt out of the study in advance.

Is this a case where the Jehovah's Witnesses in question understand the new policy that permits the use of hemoglobin and object to it to the point of speaking in the media? No - I don't believe so. It is highly uncharacteristic for Witnesses to oppose Watchtower policy publicly.

What we have here is the result of the Watchtower Writing Department's careful attempt to obfuscate the new policy. Both Jehovah's Witnesses and medical professionals alike are confused by the mixed message the Watchtower is sending. Note the following email we received from a Jehovah's Witness:

Hi, I am studying with Jehovah's Witnesses, I used to be one years and years ago.  I am now an RN.  I recently read the 6/15/04 article on blood and have also visited your website.  You have a chart which actually adds to the chart in the 6/15/04 Watchtower article.  In yours, you list hemoglobin substitutes as acceptable to JW's.  I don't see that in the Watchtower article and got on the Watchtower and Bible Tract Society website and did not see any such substitutes listed under alternatives.  Your article stating they accepted hemoglobin substitutes interested me because hemoglobin is a major component of the red blood cell and actually allows the red blood cell to carry its oxygen.  Without it, blood is no longer life-giving.  Where did you get your information on hemoglobin-based blood substitutes being acceptable to Jehovah's Witnesses?

Here is an individual who has the added benefit of being a registered nurse, has read the Watchtower's published statements and is still unable to accurately assess just what the policy is!

One would think that by continuing to state policy in such an unclear manner, the Watchtower Society is not only permitting confusion among its members, it is promoting it. That such confusion and misunderstanding will lead to the refusal of potentially life saving transfusions of PolyHeme and other hemoglobin based blood products is seems highly probable.

It is our sincere hope that the leadership of the Watchtower Society will direct the writing department to publish very clear guidelines and directives in this regard to clear up this confusion among Jehovah's Witnesses. Respect for life demands nothing less.

Legal Developments

March 23, 2005
by Lawrence Hughes

I won the court hearing yesterday. The attempt by the Watchtower Society to have portions of my affidavit struck down was unsuccessful. Four days have been set aside for the next court hearing - April 25- 28, 2005.  This next hearing is the BIG one. All the Watchtower lawyers from Canada will be there either as defendants or representing defendants  including all the defendants and Watchtower representatives involved in the case. If they succeed, my lawsuit will be thrown out. It is imperative that I get as many persons to support the protest rally as possible. The more persons at the rally, the more media coverage. The more media coverage, the more likely the Judge will decide in my favor and allow this lawsuit to go to trial. If this case goes to trial, it will be the most publicized trial in Canadian history. 

I am also organizing a protest rally in Toronto in front of the Ontario Legislature Building, Friday, June 24th from 12:00 noon until about 3:00 pm. The issues will be about the many Jehovah Witnesses dying each day regarding the Watchtower Society's prohibition on blood transfusions and on the protecting of pedophiles in the organization.

I am also having a protest rally in Georgetown, Ontario, Saturday, June 25th at the Watch- tower Society HQ from 12:00 noon to 3:00 pm. I do not expect people to support both. The protest at the Ontario Legislature is the more important one. It should get national, if not world news coverage.

Please let me know if you can attend. Please use the email address below for this and feel free to give it out to others. Thanks and please spread the word.

to_protest_rally@yahoo.ca

P.S. - I will be conducting a Memorial for those victims who died refusing blood transfusions. Anyone who has lost a loved one due to the WTS prohibition on blood can send me a photo with a write up of what happened, name, date, etc. for the memorial. It would be best if they could come in person and talk to the media.

Announcements and Member Requests

From AJWRB members in Czechoslovakia:


We have prepared a new book about JW´s and blood in Czech language. Its title is: “Life is sacred – Christians and the question of blood in Bible”. The book consists about 230 pages including info from AJWRB web site,  life experiences and personal expressions from Czech republic too. For example, a professor of theology wrote one chapter, and the manager of a transfusion center and doctor wrote other chapters.

We want to publish 1000 copies at first edition. Target language group comprises 42,000 of memorial attendance in Czech and Slovak republics. (About 15 million peoples live in our countries.) The cost is going to be about $2,500 We have raised two thousand dollars. 

Can you support our book by sending 500 dollars?

 

If you are interested in supporting this effort, please contact us for additional instructions.




URGENT - I need an opinion from a Pediatric Oncologist. I need a Pediatric Oncologist to quickly review some medical records and give an opinion on whether blood transfusions would have allowed Bethany a chance to live long enough to find a treatment that would have offered her a chance to live. Also, if she had not received Arsenic Trioxide would there have been a possibility that she would have survived. Please send me contact information for an Oncologist A.S.A.P.
 Please email info to freechristian2002@yahoo.com.

Thanks - 
Lawrence <>


News Reports

A Jehovah's Witness couple in Texas refused a medically necessary blood transfusion for their newborn child. This is a truly shocking development that deserves our attention. You can view the story here and you can discuss this development here.

Here is a transcript of the report:

Karen Borta (anchor): Tonight, a local hospital is forced to go to court to provide urgent medical care for a baby. Tracy Rowlett (anchor): This case pits religious beliefs against the law, and it all started when twins were born prematurely at Baylor Medical Center in Dallas. When their parents would not consent to life-saving medical treatment, the hospital then went to court. CBS 11's Jack Fink joins us live tonight with the exclusive details. Jack? Jack Fink (reporter): Tracy, court documents show the couple would not consent to the treatment because it would violate their religious beliefs. A judge has sided with the hospital and ordered the treatments, but we've learned that one of the twins has since died. Court records show Tara and Embre Speciale were born on Valentine's Day. Each weighed less than two pounds. But the next day, the Baylor Medical Center in Dallas filed a petition in court, asking a judge to intervene. Doctors said the children would likely need a transfusion of red blood cells, which would enable the children's blood to carry sufficient oxygen to sustain life. But the baby's parents are Jehovah's Witnesses, and it is against the Jehovah's Witness religion to accept such treatment. Doctors told the judge: "If the blood product treatment is delayed, there is a significant risk of death or serious complications." Thomas Mayo, a professor at SMU and a medical ethicist, couldn't comment on this specific case, but says in general the law supports the hospital's position. Thomas Mayo: What they're not entitled to do under the law is to withhold blood transfusions from their minor children. Jack Fink: In his order, Judge Robert Frost prevented the babies' parents from disrupting or interfering with the treatment. The Judge also ordered that Baylor Medical Center provide all treatment that is reasonably necessary to stabilize the condition or prevent death. The babies' parents didn't return our calls seeking comment, and the hospital declined commenting on the case. Professor Mayo says there is a simple rationale for the law. Thomas Mayo: An adult is entitled to make that decision for himself or herself, and that minor children have a legal right to grow into adulthood and make that decision for themselves when they are old enough. Jack Fink: Now Jehovah's Witnesses we spoke with say they have a very high regard for life and that they are not anti-medicine. They say they try to find doctors who use treatments other than blood transfusions. We're live in Dallas tonight, Jack Fink, CBS 11 News.


India News – Siliguri  Oct 9, 2004

The father of a critically ill baby girl, who took her away from the Siliguri Sadar Hospital to avoid a blood transfusion as it was against his faith was persuaded by the authorities that it was necessary to save the child's life.

The two and a half years old baby girl, Manorama Lakra, suffering from acute anemia diarrhea, was admitted to the Sadar Hospital on October seven, Darjeeling Superintendent of Police Rajiv Mishra said today.

The baby's father, Sanjay Lakra, a member of Jehovah's Witness, refused when doctors told him that she needed a blood transfusion to save her life saying it was against his faith. He then ran away with his baby girl, Mishra said.

The Jehovah's Witness is a Christian sect that denies many traditional Christian doctrines and preaches the Second Coming.

Sanjay, a resident of Labour Bustee of the Bagdogra Tea Garden, and his daughter were traced by the authorities that same evening and persuaded to return to the hospital, Mishra said, where Manorama was given a transfusion.

She was given a second blood transfusion today, Dr A K Saha, under whom she was admitted said, adding that the baby girl's condition had improved.

The blood was provided by the North Bengal Voluntary Blood Donors Forum, said its Secretary Pijush Kanti Ray who together with the police superintendent were instrumental in convincing the father and bringing the baby back to the hospital. PTI



Experiences

Thoughts expressed are those of the individual and may not reflect the views of all members or AJWRB.

From Ruth (McGill) Baker of the Asheboro, NC congregation in 2001

Two JW women, fleshy sisters, by the name of Louise and Bessie had found out they had developed leukemia after some years of suffering another blood disorder called hemochromatosis.  Louise and Bessie by this time were both in their early 80’s when they found this out - they both had leukemia independently.

Treatment that could prolong their lives would require the use of blood transfusions which they both refused because they were devoted Jehovah’s Witnesses.  Doctors felt they could probably have lived quite a long time with other added treatments combined with the blood transfusion treatments.  Bessie and Louise refused because of their firm belief in the Watchtower’s policy on blood. To accept blood would cause them to face disfellowshipping from the congregation which they could not bear - not even to save their lives. The doctors told them it would hasten their death without blood transfusions. The doctor’s hands were tied.

The two sisters were originally from Canada and had lived in the Asheboro, North Carolina area for many years serving faithfully all their lives. They had been second generation JW’s, and proud of it.  Bessie had been a pioneer for nearly 30 plus years and finally married late in her life. Louise had served faithfully with her JW husband all her life. Both sisters had even resisted having children because of believing the end was always near.  Now those lives were about to end due to a WTS policy.

Louise died first in 1999 and Bessie just months later in 2000.  The congregation I was in at the time cheered them on praising them for being so brave refusing blood transfusions. They lived less than 6 months after developing leukemia.  These two sisters died believing they were giving honor to the God they worshiped and the religious organization that promised them everlasting life because of their willingness to refuse blood transfusions.

From a Young Man named Matt Schell of Rio Rancho, New Mexico:

In 1969 I was born to parents whom were witnesses for about 4-5 years.

When I was 14, almost 15 I developed a duodenal ulcer that positioned itself right on the main artery in the GI tract. So one morning I forgot to flush the toilet (in a lot of pain and lightheaded), and my mom discovered this enormous amount of blood I’d lost. She immediately took me to the doctor. At the doctor’s office, he withdrew some blood while I passed out 2 more times, and he sent me home. Much later I found out our Doctor sent me home so he could buy some time to get an emergency court order to force a transfusion because of my parents being Jehovah’s Witnesses. He knew it would take a blood transfusion to save my life. Now my mother had been a nurses aide for several years, and knew something was wrong, so she was very worried.

This is where I believe Jehovah stepped in. After we got home, and I was lying on the couch looking at my hands and my fingernails realizing they were totally white.  My mother had forgotten to pay the doctor, so she had a JW neighbor keep an eye on me while she rushed back to pay the doctor. We had just moved into this house, so the doctor did not have our new address or phone number. He had planned on calling an ambulance as soon as he got the court order which was unknown to us. Had my mother not returned immediately to pay the bill & update our address, the ambulance would have never found me.

At the hospital the surgeon and team were awaiting us. I overheard his conversation with my parents and remember them saying distinctly, "We do not believe in blood transfusions, ask our son and he will tell you the same thing -we’re Jehovah’s Witnesses". So my parents told me what was going on, and told me that I needed a blood transfusion, and reminded me of what Jehovah said about blood transfusions. I remember exactly what I was thinking as if it was 5 minutes ago. I thought, “If I accept a blood transfusion, Jehovah is going to kill me because of it”. So I said “no, I didn't want one, I didn't want to die.” And I remember the smile that came across mothers face when I said no. I could see my parents were so proud of me. Then the surgeon came in to talk to me, my parents to his back, he told me I needed a blood transfusion, but he would try to do what ever he could to make sure it didn't come to that. I remember the very nice 'gas man' as he put me to sleep for the surgery.  I was later told that they had given me a blood transfusion to save my life, otherwise I would have died.

When coming to, I remember my mom telling me that the elders were there, and how everyone was so proud of me for my decision to refuse blood. That was all they could talk about for a good while.  It was even publicly announced from the platform of the decision I made to refuse blood transfusions! How brave I was, they all said. I heard my mother say she would never yell at me again. I was told how my decision convinced a woman, whom was studying, to dedicate herself. I never met this woman though it was told to me very enthusiastically.

After the surgery I had several complications and ended up spending about 3 months in the hospital. I started to question my decision the day another doctor had to feed me intravenously for 3 weeks, since I couldn't keep any food down. I became incredibly scared, and confused about the forced blood transfusion the hospital had given me.  I thought for sure Jehovah was going to kill me now, or at least was punishing me with these complications. The elders told me not to worry about that because it was the fact of my stand of refusing the blood transfusion, not that I received it, that Jehovah was looking at. My parents knew the truth and never sued the hospital, because the blood transfusion in truth had saved my life. The congregation continued to believe my complications were a result of forced blood transfusions, rather than the truth of my true medical problems.

I never thought about it after I became well. Then a couple of years ago I realized it was that torturous decision that was causing some post-traumatic stress symptoms, and I sought therapy for 2 years. I finally took a look at what the Bible really said about blood. I studied with a brother for 6 months, and I told him, I would never be able to accept the societies teaching on transfusions. So I was informed I would never be allowed to be a publisher, nor be baptized. There were a few other things I questioned, but the main issue was blood.

To disfellowship someone on this issue is not godly. I believe that refusing to baptize someone because of this issue is a form of pharmaceutical judgment, and borders on blaspheming God. It hurts that I am now considered an apostate all because of the blood issue. But I do know one thing, Jehovah and Jesus still love me no matter what I think, or believe. I believe Jehovah allowed me to receive a transfusion. Was it because of my faith in him, I don't know? That is still confusing to me even now.

But thank you for letting me tell my story, and I hope this will help someone decide for themselves if the Watchtower Bible Tract Society teachings on blood transfusions are really from Jehovah, or from men.

Matt

From another of our readers an experience with name removed to protect identity:

Thanks you for your informative website. I am a former JW who received four blood transfusions in February 2004.  I had a serious hemorrhage, with slim chance of survival, after the birth of my fifth baby.  My hemoglobin fell below 50 and I received packed red blood cells. Through this process I have learned a lot, which I think a lot of JW’s are not aware of. The much touted 'blood expanders' that are allowed are often held up as being all that is needed in place of blood transfusions.  This is most certainly not the case. In fact, what these blood expanders do is to dilute the blood that is left after a serious blood loss. This diluting makes the hemoglobin drop all the lower, as happened to me, so the red blood cells are needed all the more.  Blood expanders were needed regardless of the receipt or non-receipt of blood so avoiding them would not have avoided the need to blood products.  Simply put, blood expanders are not an answer.

I have five beautiful children and a loving husband who need their mother. I would not have been prepared to die for a teaching that is based on two scriptures that pertain to the EATING of blood.  I can't imagine that God would give me these children and then not want me to do all I could to be there for them.

I'm sure a lot of JW’s would also be disappointed to know that I have been tested for all the diseases and found free of any. They like to scare you with their exaggerated stories of disease associated with blood. The risk is very low in the first place when it comes to blood transfusions thanks to modern science.

I could never let my child die for want of blood.  Keep up the good work all of you at AJWRB.ORG.

Reform

We regularly receive requests from individuals wanting to assist AJWRB with our educat- ional work. We have prepared an entire section of the web site with ideas and suggestions in this regard.

Additionally, you can  help AJWRB by supporting our efforts to inform and educate physicians and other health care professionals. This work requires both time and money - resources are necessary to push forward further reforms. If AJWRB has helped you personally, please make a small donation today.

Website - What's New

We have recovered lost images and updated the article: 

Watchtower Leaders Caught in Deception

We have added a site map - but it is a work in progress.

Mail Bag


I have recently withdrawn my DPA ( the WTS version) from my medical file because I cannot agree with their position on blood transfusions. I would, though, like to have one that can give me the choices such as "end of life" and other advice's concerning the cautions on the use of blood products.  Would you be able to advise me is there such a DPA that one can obtain?  I
know on the AJWRB there is a proposed one but not in it's final form.

If you are in the United States, check with your "Secretary of State" to see if they provide a "living will" and/or "Durable Power of Attorney - Medical". You will need to add any provisions you believe are necessary concerning the use of blood or blood products.



Despite the fact that my wife and I have separated ourselves from the organization due to conscience, we do receive occasional news from those in our former hall. Recently, we got news that an elder there was diagnosed with a disorder that typically requires blood transfusions as treatment. With the help of AJWRB website I was able to clearly (in spite of not staying in touch or reading the magazines at all anymore) discuss with his daughter the options of use of hemoglobin products now allowed by the society. I have no idea if they will pursue this direction, but wanted to express appreciation that the info on the site is so well detailed and accurate that it allowed me to be of some assistance.
 

Thank you for your diligent efforts here. May God bless you and the staff at AJWRB.

Annonymous


My name is Jose L. Ortiz, Sr. and it is Ok if the entire human race knows about what I am writing.  So, you have my permission to place my sister's name Mirta Soto Lebron in your list of known human sacrifices by Jehovah's Witnesses….My Sister, who was a Jehovah's Witness for about 25 years, refused a blood transfusion and died November 16, 2004.   I am a former Jehovah's Witness myself and I know the basic false doctrine on the issue of blood.  However, in the case of my sister, many details about the way the Witnesses handled or mishandled her so called "refusal" are highly questionable. 

In my estimation, the Witnesses have fouled up this case extremely negligently and even daringly.  It would take much time to explain this case and frankly I don't know how much good it would do, except for informational purposes.  Therefore, I am limiting this email to only general information and a request.  Since your organization seems to deal with these issues more widely, I would like to inquire on whether or not you are affiliated with experienced trial Lawyers relating to Jehovah's Witnesses deaths due to blood issues.  If not, do you know of any lawyers experienced with such cases?  I believe our case is extremely unique and worthy of a good legal look.  Thanking you I will await your response.


I am an elder…last week the circuit overseer demonstrated to the body of elders that someone whose blood is taken by the cell saver can be stored outside the body, taken into another room of the hospital and then be radiated in case of cancer. Here is the explanation that he offered:  “You can see it as if you have cut off your finger and go to the surgeon to fit it again on your hand. You see it as a part of you”. What did the Germans say, “wash my fur but don’t wet my skin”?

Anonymous


I know first hand the devastation caused by the watchtower society's stand on blood. My aunt refused a blood transfusion several years ago and laid in a coma for 3 years before dying.  I am writing to you to let you know that I would like to get involved in this issue here in my own town. I would personally like to visit the local hospitals and speak with the E.R doctors about the JW stance on blood transfusions. I am willing to give of my time for this cause, and
willing to help people going through these emotionally draining circumstances.

See a discussion of what you can do in our section on Reform.


    I am a Jehovah's Witness looking to make an educated decision on my bloodless medicine directives. I have found your site most informative. I would also like to see more reforms. I am not an elder, but I am in good standing.
    Please don't be bitter with our founding elders…things were different back then and the WTS is now ready to accept modern advances. Now is not the time to recall lost lives, or keep an, "I told you so attitude."
    Our congregation has recently had a visit from a Liaison committee member from Bethel. He told us of many JW's now with free conscious are using minor blood fractions. He gave ne example of a young child having a liver transplant, in a bloodless surgery. Some other examples of witnesses having transfusions of their own blood that had been removed, treated, and returned in a short time, so as to keep a circulation going. This member also made us aware of a modern technology to omit the outer membrane of a blood cell and harvest the inner properties to form a minor fraction that could be taken by one who felt that it would not offend our God of love.

    I wish our society would compromise the issue of storing our own blood to use on ourselves. It seems like the next easiest issue to reform. Perhaps they are afraid of changes coming too quickly.

    If I were on your team, I would have the Liaison member read from the bible, Romans 13:1 and 2 where it says that we should be in subjection to the authorities of this system, Judges, educated scholars, doctors of medicine such as yourselves.

    Look at Mathew 23:1-3. It tells of how the religious leaders of that day put an unnecessary burden on the people, by adding to the limits of the law. Look at Mathew 23:23 It says, "you have disregarded the weightier matters of the law namely justice and MERCY..."
  I hope this message will help you. Remember, "attitude is everything."

Annonymous


Dear Brothers,
 
We wanted to call your attention to a new Jehovah's Witnesses reform site. Like your own project, it is designed to encourage change in the some of the organization's policies. Please check it out. We hope some of you would appreciate it.
 
Yours truly,
 

I want to thank you and the rest on AJWRB for you past and current work on this blood topic.  I currently always ask JWs how they can accept a blood fraction such as hemoglobin-based products when they are made out of large amounts of stored blood.  I get 2 reactions, one they agree with me that it is confusing and they can't accept the product or get angry and say that the WTS says it is all right so they are going to accept it.

I have changed all my medical instructions so that I will accept all blood products if necessary and I now donate my own blood, popular universal donor that I am.

Thanks, Blondi

Crisis and Intervention

We are attempting to put together an interview with Steven Hassan which we hope to publish for our readers in our next issue.

The AJWRB newsletter is published several times each year to keep members up to date on recent developments. Members are encouraged to contact us with their thoughts, ideas and suggestions as well as to submit content for publishing. While we cannot publish all material received, we do carefully consider all submissions.


The Associated Jehovah's Witnesses for Reform on Blood, is a diverse group of Witnesses from over 25 countries, including elders and other organization officials, Hospital Liaison Committee members, doctors and members of the general public. All have volunteered their time and energies in an effort to bring about an end to a tragic and misguided policy that has claimed thousands of lives, many of them children.

Website:  http://www.ajwrb.org       Email:  info@ajwrb.org

"Never doubt that a small committed group of citizens can change the world.
Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has." Margret Mead

 Please support our educational work, send your contribution to:

AJWRB
 P.O. Box 190089
Boise, ID 83719-0089 U.S.A.